Mini Reviews: Going Too Far & Fangirl


Going Too Far by Jennifer Echols

Publisher: Pocket Books/MTV Books

Release Date: March 17, 2009

Pages: 245

Source: Bought

Rating: 4 out of 5

Going Too Far is my first foray into Jennifer Echols’ books! I honestly wasn’t sure what to expect because I know Echols is a popular contemporary writer, but some people don’t like her books. In a way, I went into Going Too Far with no expectations. The reader is introduced to the main character Meg, a fiery girl with vibrant blue hair. The first scene we find her in is of her making out with a no-strings-attached boy by the train tracks, and her getting arrested for loitering. The reader doesn’t get the best impression of Meg, but talk about hook, line, and sinker. I somehow got sucked into Meg’s story! Going Too Far is an addicting read – similar to the way that New Adult is addicting – and I’m very pleased with my first read of Jennifer Echols’. The romantic relationship that builds between herself and the young cop is slow, burning, and extremely satisfying. If all of Jennifer Echols’ romances are this good, call me her newest fan.


Fangirl by Rainbow Rowell

Publisher: St. Martin’s Griffin

Release Date: September 10, 2013

Pages: 433

Source: Bought

Rating: 4.5 out of 5

Rainbow Rowell is magic. Her words form perfection and her writing style that crafts these characters are just so incredibly lovable. Fangirl was no exception.

The first of many qualities that I loved about Fangirl was most definitely the relatability of the characters. Cath is an identical twin entering freshman year of college, which, is pretty much me. I couldn’t help but love Cath instantly because I understood her like THAT. She’s absorbed into her fanfiction stories of Simon Snow, a story much like Harry Potter in our world. I could totally see myself in Cath’s shoes, holed up in my dorm room in just a few short months, except reading, not writing fanfic. Cath’s relationship with her dormmate, Levi, and her twin sister are distinct and they really helped shape her into a well-rounded character. Lots of obstacles come in front of Cath’s path as a new adult, and I feel that Rowell did portrayed a new adult’s decision realistically through Cath.

The one drawback in Fangirl was the little snippets and excerpts of Simon Snow and Cath’s fanfiction of Simon Snow. I was much more invested in Cath and Levi’s story, and I felt that the Simon Snow aspects drew the attention away from Cath too much. However, it does add an element of authenticity, as I’m sure every reader is a fangirl of Harry Potter, making Cath all the more relatable.

Fangirl was un-put-down-able, addicting, and simply magical. I will always be a sucker for Rainbow Rowell’s contemporaries because of her writing style, adorable romances, and well-crafted characters. Fangirl is a must read for all contemporary lovers!


7 thoughts on “Mini Reviews: Going Too Far & Fangirl”

  1. JEN JEN JEN!!!!! These mini reviews are everything. I’m so so excited to see such a glowing review of Fangirl. I just read Eleanor and Park recently, so I know exactly what you mean about Rowell’s writing being fantastic. And from your review, it seems that I’ll be able to connect with Fangirl way more than I was able to with E&P, because Cath sounds totally like me too! (Without the identical twin bit, though). And yessss, I LOVE Jennifer Echols, so happy you finally picked up one of her books. This sounds amazing and addicting and now I’ve added BOTH to my TBR list! Thanks for the lovely mini-reviews, Jen. 🙂 x


  2. I’m so glad you finally got around to reading Fangirl! I really enjoyed it myself–Attachments is still my favorite Rowell read, though–but this is a close second. Also, Echols usually never works for me but Going too Far was one I really enjoyed. I probably need to re-read it since I read it waaaaay too long ago. Fantastic mini-reviews, Jen! 🙂


    1. I’ll have to check out ATTACHMENTS very soon!! I’m sad that Jennifer Echols’ other books don’t really work for you, but I’m glad you liked GOING TOO FAR as well 🙂


  3. Yessss SO pleased that you loved Fangirl!! That’s what New Adult SHOULD be like, right?? Cath’s story was just SO relatable.

    Oh, but does this mean you have no intention of reading Carry On when it comes out later this year because you weren’t as interested in Simon and Baz’s story?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s